Bechoros Daf 60 בכורות דַף 60

Create Your Free Zichru Account צור את חשבון Zichru שלך

To discover the power of remembering the daf and view this audio lesson, please create a free Zichru account. To discover the power of remembering the daf and view this audio lesson, please create a free Zichru account.

CREATE ACCOUNT צור חשבון

1. If one misnumbered the ninth, tenth, and eleventh animals

The next Mishnah states: קרא לתשיעי עשירי ולעשירי תשיעי ולאחד עשר עשירי – if one called the ninth animal which exited the pen “tenth,” and called the tenth one “ninth,” and the eleventh one “tenth,” שלשתן מקודשין – the three of them are sanctified, but with different halachos: the ninth may not be sacrificed, but may be eaten after developing a מום. The true tenth is full-fledged maaser, and the eleventh is offered as a shelamim. Rebbe Meir says the eleventh animal can produce a תמורה, i.e., if one substitutes another animal for it, it also becomes a shelamim. Rebbe Yehudah argues: וכי יש תמורה עושה תמורה – is there any temurah that can produce another temurah? He interprets the eleventh animal’s kedushah as a “temurah” of the tenth, which cannot produce another temurah. They replied in Rebbe Meir’s name that the eleventh cannot be a temurah: אילו היה תמורה לא היה קרב – had it been a temurah, it would not be offered, because the temurah of maaser is not offered. Rather, it is an ordinary shelamim, and can produce a temurah. If one called the ninth, tenth, and eleventh animals "עשירי", the eleventh does not become sanctified, because the rule is: כל שלא נעקר שם עשירי ממנו – wherever the designation as “tenth” was not uprooted [from the true tenth], אין אחד עשר מקודש – the eleventh is not sanctified.

2. One who counted his animals in pairs

Rebbe Yochanan said: מנאן זוגות זוגות – if one counted [his animals] in pairs, or in hundreds, i.e., after two (or a hundred) animals passed under the staff, he counted them as “one,” and continued until he counted “ten,” עשירי [למנין] הוא קדוש – the tenth according to the count is sanctified as maaser. Amoraim debate which “tenth” Rebbe Yochanan meant: Rav Mari said למנין שלו הוא קדוש – [the tenth] is sanctified according to his own count, i.e., every tenth pair, or every tenth group of a hundred, is maaser. Rav Kahana says למנין בהמות הוא קדוש – [the tenth] is sanctified according to the true count of the animals, i.e., every tenth animal which exited the pen is sanctified, and the owner’s count is disregarded.

A Baraisa teaches that if one counted למפרע – backwards from ten to one, the tenth to leave (which he called “one”) is maaser. Although Rav Mari says we follow the owner’s count, Rava answers that in the Persian method of counting, they call ten “one,” so this is a legitimate designation of “tenth.”

3. Two animals exited simultaneously as ninth, or as tenth

Rava said: יצאו שנים בתשיעי – if two animals exited simultaneously as ninth, then if he called them “ninth,” עשירי וחולין מעורבין זה בזה – then they are a sanctified tenth and an animal of chullin which are mixed; the tenth is maaser automatically, and the ninth remains chullin, since he called it “ninth.” If he called them "עשירי", then they are a sanctified maaser and sanctified ninth mixed together, according to the Mishnah’s law of a misnumbered ninth. If two animals exited simultaneously as tenth, then if he called them “tenth,” they are a maaser and sanctified eleventh mixed together. If he called them “eleventh,” they are a maaser and chullin mixed together. This case teaches that although an eleventh animal is only sanctified if the designation of the tenth was נעקר – uprooted (i.e., he called it “ninth”), כל בת אחת תרווייהו קא קדשי – wherever they were designated as “tenth” simultaneously, they are both sanctified, ואף על גב דלא נעקר שם עשירי הימנו – even though the designation as “tenth” was not uprooted [from the true tenth].

Copyright זכויות יוצרים © 2026 Zichru